Selma's Chicago Pizzeria & Tap Room RSM 30461 Avenida de las Flores, Rancho Santa Margarita, CA 92688

"Wonderful food and great drinks. Great service except for one thing. The last three times I've been here, I've tried to get an Artisan pizza with just Pepperoni. I've even specifically said "No mushrooms, please" and had the server acknowledge that. And the last three times I've tried, somebody along the way doesn't get the "No mushrooms" memo and they put mushrooms on the pizza. If I had a nickel every time this team has ignored my request for no mushrooms, I'd have three nickels, which isn't a lot but it's weird that it's happened this consistently. PLEASE do better."

"Good Italian/pizza. Had the lasagna which I wish had more pasta inside. Maybe should have ordered the baked ziti instead. Both Caesar and Greek salads are amazing and the small is definitely not small."

"Love the food here usually the fettuccine is super creamy and saucy but tonight it was on the dryer side called selmas the next day and they absolutely made it right kudos to the manager Mike your the best"

"First time here. I saw the sign off Santa Margarita for years. Just never stopped here. I had a few free moments in the area so I decided to give it a try. I love pizza. The place was pretty quite as it was after lunch. Staff was super attentive. I ordered a Da'Vinny personal lunch special. Deep dish Pizza and a salad. The salad was quite generous and delicious. The blue cheese was nice and strong if you know what I mean. The crust of the pizza was perfect. Crispy. But not too hard. The pepperoni, Italian sausage, and marinara sauce were a perfect balance. Definitely will come back. And recommended"

"$4 beer, $4 soup and a $14 Calzone with 2 toppings. I really liked the Honey Blonde House Brew and the soup was very good - with the exception that it should be served with some type of bread. The bar tender asked me right away if I wanted a dinner roll and after the first was done I asked for another which was not an issue. Overall the place has a great atmosphere, low playing current and past rock music from various time periods. The tables are clean, the people are friendly, the waiters, servers and hosts are on point and I will be back. Unless my Calzone fails, they earned 4 stars. They lost 1 point because I was asked to wait for the manager to place my order at the restaurant and they never came. When I walked over to the bar, they gave me service right away."