Mama Cimino's Pizza

"Talk about a diamond in the rough. We ordered one of the specials (a 24" pizza, 10 wings a two liter) and it was more than we could eat. But it was well worth it. The wings were cooked perfectly. When our waitress said the wings were the size of her first, she wasn't joking. The pizza awesome. Our waitress was fantastic. We will be back for sure. If it's not the number #1 pizza in Lake Geneva, it should be!"

"Service and food was amazing! We ordered the Friday pizza special (pizza, wings and soda) and it was so much food! Biggest wings I've seen in a long time. Such a great value! Our waitress was very friendly. Can't wait to come back!"

"Great service and even better food! Staff is really friendly and makes you feel like a valued customer. Food comes out really quick but is still high quality and tastes fresh, and prices are excellent for the amount of food, especially when it comes to pizza. Atmosphere is nice with various entertainment and beautiful decor no matter what time of year. No visit to Lake Geneva is complete without a visit to Mama Cimino's! Highly recommend for a late night bite."

"Came for a last minute weekend away and had a craving for some delicious ‘Za. Mama Cimino’s did not disappoint! Great crust, sauce and homemade sausage! Super yummy and affordable! Will definitely try again next time I’m in town!"

"Stacy took great care of us, even though the place was really busy, making sure we had everything we needed and more! Lots to choose from on the menu, too. Great take on the traditional margarita pizza! Thank you, Stacy!!"