Backstreet Pizza

"Good food, good restaurant. But if they forget things in your delivery order they tell you it's not they're problem and they'll just mark you down to get them for free next time you order. So if you order multiple sauces with your food don't expect to get it most of the time when you order delivery."

"Usually impressed, but this time we were not. The poor server was too overwhelmed and could not handle the amount of tables. Also the prices went up TWO dollars from what was on the menu and it was NEVER mentioned. That’s just unacceptable, you can’t expect people to just be able to pay the extra two dollars if they didn’t know there was a price difference."

"Here is an interesting restaurant in Sullivan. I'm not sure how many restaurants are in town but this place has a cool garage vibe to it. The decorations and ambiance are nice. The staff was great and the pizza came out fast. The pizza is decent- we got hand tossed crust, and the pizzas are piled high with toppings. It's a bit greasy, but that's pizza. Prices are reasonable so no complaints from me. It was refreshing to try something other than the cracker crust style prevalent in southern Indiana."

"Hitting up more Pizza places took me to Backstreet Pizza. The atmosphere here is fantastic. The garage feel, the cars, connecting rod art, custom pinstriped pieces, magazine articles on the floor, "Assembly Manual" menus. Well done! The waitress was very friendly. The garlic knots for an appetizer were good. Nice amount of garlicky flavor. Bread had good snap and chewiness. The pizza ordered by my party was the "Gangbuster" which has sausage, bacon, ham, Canadian bacon, pepperoni and Italian sausage. With this many toppings I'm shocked it didn't impress me more. The dough has fantastic snap when it first came out, however the second slice has lost its crunch. Nothing in the way of the dough or sauce stood out, however to be fair it had so many toppings. I found it to be just okay. It was also quite greasy as seen on cardboard after Pizza was consumed. Again, lots of toppings would be greasy. I am going to come back and get just a cheese to try, and I will update this review at that time. All in all the garlic bread was good, Pizza ok to me, atmosphere was excellent. Plenty of parking. Nice staff."

"This must be the happening go-to place in Sullivan. It's a hip converted garage with a great shop/car vibe. Even the bathrooms were decorated in that theme! Good food, good service. The Alfredo pizza was tasty. Even the salads were good -crisp, cold and fresh. Worth trying just for the ambiance."