Aurelio's Pizza

"My husband ordered from here because he knows we love Aurelio’s Pizza. We normal order from the one in Winfield. I sure wish he had. The pizza was delivered was burnt, dry and look disgusting. We told them and they made a new pizza that still was over cooked. It was disgusting and looked like old tops were put on it. I’ll never order from here again. They were very nice to try and replace it but we are all sick now from this pizza."

"We ordered a medium pizza and a large caabrese. The dough on the cslabrese was raw around the edges and the cheese tasted funny. The pizza was one of the worst I've had. Over-cooked, SO salty, just gross. We threw it away."

"My favorite pizza place but they dropped the ball. Pizza was over cooked to little sauce and cheese but over loaded with sausage. Took the leftovers home and asked for pizza sauce to go for dipping. Just a very disappointing experience for the family. For $130 I expect more. Guess I'll make the drive to the Homewood location from now on."

"Aurelio's Pizza is a beloved pizzeria that holds a special place in the hearts of many, thanks to its founder, Papa Joe. The restaurant continues to honor his legacy with mouthwatering pizza offerings that have stood the test of time. Papa Joe's dedication to quality ingredients and a secret family recipe still shines through in every bite. While Papa Joe may no longer be with us, his passion for crafting exceptional pizza lives on at Aurelio's, making it a cherished destination for those seeking a slice of tradition and a taste of the past."

"The pizza was undercooked. I didn’t want to complain so I figured I would try a slice. It was not even very hot. I stopped eating it and told the waitress (Lauren - Laur S) it wasn’t right. I asked if it could be cooked more. She told me that because I took a slice off, there was nothing she could do and walked away. She didn’t try to fix it or anything. She came back to our table one time toward the end. I finally had to go find her to get a box to take the pizza home in (so I could finish cooking it). When she asked if everything was good, I again told her no. The pizza sucked. I told her right away everything wasn’t ok. I then could hear her talking about my table and how we were complaining as I got up to leave. I looked at her and told her I could hear her as my table butted right up to the waitress station. She told me “I know.” What a cocky, immature waitress she is. She finally offered to discount it. At that point I just wanted to get out of there and not deal with her anymore. It was a terrible, expensive experience. It was $3.75 just for a root beer that I had one of because I didn’t even like the pizza."