Renew Consignment

"Renew Consignment is truly a hidden gem for anyone who loves the thrill of the hunt. Nestled in a deceptively large space, this consignment shop offers a delightful array of high-end items and antique treasures. Whether you're in the market for fashion, jewelry, furniture, or home goods, Renew has an eclectic selection that caters to a variety of tastes. One of the most refreshing aspects of this shop is its pricing. Unlike some vintage stores that seem to overestimate the value of their items, Renew Consignment prices its finds in a way that feels both fair and exciting. It's that rare kind of place where you can score incredible deals without compromising on quality—a true boon for the savvy thrifter. The sheer size of the store is a wonder in itself. It stretches nearly an entire block, but don't let that intimidate you—the space is thoughtfully organized, making the shopping experience not just manageable, but utterly enjoyable. Every corner turned presents a new collection to explore, each with its own story and potential to be the next great addition to your home or wardrobe. Renew Consignment isn't just a shop; it's a journey through a world of carefully curated items, each with a past and a promise of a future in a new home. It's the kind of place you recommend to friends with a knowing smile, confident that they too will be charmed and surprised by the value and variety on offer. So if you're in the area and have a penchant for discovery, don't hesitate to dive into this treasure trove."

"This place is such a gem! Great prices and selection. Dee was delightful and helped us find everything we were looking for. I scored a pair of amazing bone colored cowboy boots in mint condition for $22. Highly recommend!"

"This shop had a great selection that is absolutely worth looking through. Great deals and great people running the shop! They have a great eye for pieces and are the most wonderful people you’ll meet. I look forward to stopping back the next time in Michigan City!"

"The owner and staff were so warm and welcoming. A beautiful space with lovely finds both modern and vintage. Was in town on a family getaway and it was the perfect stop on our trip. We slipped in just an hour before closing and everyone was so kind and not at all eager to rush us out even when we realized we were keeping them late. Clothes, shoes, jewelry, hats, accessories, houseware, and furniture - so many great items to explore and a wonderful experience in the Michigan City community!"

"My group of 2 women and 2 teens from out of town visited the shop last week. We had an absolute blast - Ms. D has amazing taste and did a great job finding pieces in the shop that fit with our 2 very different teen personalities. They walked out feeling like a million bucks! Great clothes, great prices. I’m so sad this place isn’t near our home in CA. Lucky locals! I will be back again next year when I’m in town!"