Kay Jack Pizza

"Delish! We ordered a half sheet and it couldn't have been any more fresh than making it at home. The box was steaming in the cold when I took it outside. I especially liked the soft, chewy dough and that it wasn't overly greasy. Shout out to the cheesy bread and yummy sauce it comes with. Easily a new fave for a sheet pizza. *Special shout out for kind workers and exceptionally clean store."

"I had the Best pizza I have had in a longtime at Kay Jack Pizza! I am so glad to finally have GREAT pizza in Madison! I highly recommend the 1776 or the Miss Piggy. The Pulled pork is a great addition to pizza! Not to mention the cupping pepperoni just hits differently! You HAVE to try it!"

"TLDR: It's great, go buy it, it's a little more expensive then most places but get over it..... The quality justifies the price point or to support a local business that doing something awesome. Or just buy two medium cheese pizzas for 12 bucks a piece, it doesn't break the bank. Wall of Text review: Pizza snob review, and hopefully Lay Jack's gets on the One Bite app soon since it's specifically for pizza. To start, they had terrific pizza and especially for our area in Madison/Northeast Ohio it's all fast food pizza or locally owned, high efficiency, medium or low quality pizza available at other places. The cheese melted perfectly and even though we got the pepperoni it was not too greasy. We additionally tried their specially Buffalo pizza and it was very good. The additional garlic butter that they can put on your crust is highly recommended cuz it does add a lot. The reason I recommend definitely getting garlic butter is mostly tied into my one minor criticism is that the crust is quite large and takes up a lot of the space of the pizza. I'm not sure if the dough / yeast development is causing something to go haywire but the point still stands that I think the crust is a bit much. To clarify the price discussed from other reviews, Kay jack's is slightly more expensive than other local restaurants in the area. I even did a quick research because I thought I might have been misjudging. I did a comparison between Brewstreaks, Joey's/Longo's, Sammy K's and Kay Jacks. It is at worst $2 more for normal one topping pizzas and ~$4 dollars more for specialty pizza. It's not THAT bad of an upcharge for the quality you're getting. Kay jack really steps up the game in our local region. If there were other places really emphasizing truly quality Pizza pies I would probably be more scrutinizing but I have to give credit to anyone trying to really produce a high-quality pie in this area. They hit some very high marks."

"We ordered two pizzas took about twenty five minutes friendly staff service was good. Pizzas were very good I think they could have had a little bit more sauce but everybody else loved them. Thick and good crust fresh vegetables and good quality pepperoni and sausage"

"Finally found great pizza in the area. If you're like us, we've been really struggling to find good consistent pizza. We got two thin crust larges; pepperoni on one and another with sausage, yellow pepper, and olives. Excellent pizza with a really nice thin crust. Very easy to order online and make sure to punch in your phone number like the website says. I got a text 15 minutes before the pizza was to be ready so I could get there and pick it up when it was hot. If you've not been to Duffy's, park in the back of the building you can walk right in not worrying about dealing with street parking. Will be making this our regular spot from now on."