Pieology Pizzeria, Seminole

"This is one of those weird reviews. I am so happy we went here, but at the same time disappointed. There aren't any true, non-contaminated, gluten free food pizza places around Seminole/Largo area. The closest one we went to was "Your Pie" near Brandon. But my wife and I tried here. Emma couldn't have been more accommodating - ensuring my wife's meal wouldn't put her in the hospital - paying attention to every detail so the pizza would remain as gluten free as possible. My wife loved the pizza and had no ill effects afterwards. Thank you, Emma, from the bottom of my heart. I will return here whenever my wife has that pizza urge. :) Me, on the other hand. I have eaten pizza for over 50 years and have literally never complained. But for me this was the worst tasting pizza I have ever encountered. It was flimsy, the bacon wasn't cooked at all, the sauce was blagh, and the bottom was semi-burnt. I'm sure, like my wife, a lot of people love it, but it's just not for me - at all."

"We have gotten pizzas from here several times before, and it's always been pretty good.... however, our last visit, a few weeks ago, was not at all good… It's taken me this long to post this because I've been calling and waiting.... and calling and waiting....and waiting some more.... I don't really like to leave negative reviews, but after three calls during which I spoke to both Jordan and Emma, it seemed like I had no other choice....and they understood my complaint and agreed it was not going well, with, (I believe it was,) the new dough recipe. After each phone call they said they would do something about it, but I never heard back from anyone. All the pizzas (or more accurately, the loose flour underneath the pizzas,) were burnt and tasted bad, as a few others have said, although we did each eat a slice because we were hungry....One pizza was supposed to be made thick crust for a small surcharge, but it looked the same as all the others. Also, the bitter flour gets all over your fingers....it's not even so much the pizza being burnt, as the way the situation was handled.... mistakes happen, but if it would've been handled better, I probably wouldn't have even left this review.... I don't expect perfection, although I do expect when I spend $60 on pizza, for it to be mostly edible.... ****Update**** 11-3-23 After going back and forth for a few weeks with the owner, I have been provided with a full refund for these pizzas. It took a while, but I appreciate it, and think it's fair to increase my 2 star rating to a 3 star."

"The pizza is absolutely delicious! Cauliflower crust all the way!! It doesn’t taste like cauliflower at all it’s just like a very think crispy crust of deliciousness. Lots of large tables inside and outside seating as well. Only complaint is that no matter how many people are working there it takes forever to order. They are always busy because the foods so good so just plan on waiting. It will not be fast no matter how many people are ahead of you. Worth the wait though, in my opinion."

"Ordering was easy. The product itself is terrible!! Came here specifically to order gluten free and vegan for family with dietary restrictions. Both pizzas are burnt. What a disappointment. Didn't realize until I drove all the way home. Will not be back!! Was not able to call the store at all to share concerns directly. Extremely unhappy with this experience."

"Reasonably priced ‘build your own Pizza’ options. Excellence service, very happy, friendly knowledgeable staff, food order is built to your liking & baked quickly. High marks for their fresh ingredients, gluten free options and above average tasty pizza. Large clean dining area, & outdoor patio at the side of the building. Huge bonus points for extra clean washrooms. As aside point, they could be more environmentally conscious & offer customers a recycling option regarding their plastics cups & utensils."