Your Pie Pizza 2015 Highway 54 West, Peachtree City, GA 30269

"Casual dining, individually-made pizzas to order. The menu has a nice selection of their signature combinations, but you can customize them as you like, including choice of crust (white, wheat, gluten-free) and sauce (7 options). My go-to is the 10" personal size Hot Honey Pepperoni. Although, it's a chain/franchise restaurant, between the food and the atmosphere, we'll choose this over a national delivery chain every time, and this particular location is great."

"So, I am sure your regular pizzas are great. They looked great. But my husband is GF and came here after realizing you had GF crusts available. This review is based solely on the quality of your GF crusts in hopes that you can make it better. The restaurant is great. Was busy. Lots of options on the menu. We ordered a GF pizza to share with a Greek Salad. There were lots of questions multiple times from each worker is this an allergy or a preference. Which we continued to answer Allergy all the way down the line… Understand that the real question is, “Are you celiac? Or just intolerant” Celiac means you must change gloves, you must use clean utensils and you must not work on any surfaces that were used with wheat or gluten. We said allergy and was not asked any further and each person that handled our pizza never changed gloves or worked on a different surface than the regular line. My husband is NOT celiac, it is an intolerance so this is okay for him, but had he been a celiac this could have been a huge problem. So for the sake of any future patrons, ask the question , “Are you celiac or intolerant”. The staff also understanding the difference is huge. So now, let’s get to the pizza itself. We ordered a #7 margherita. Upon it arriving it was super small, not even the 10” like the regular pizza. The crust is tasteless, like I mean equivalent of styrofoam. Hard at the bottom and tasteless soft goo then minimal toppings. Barely any sauce and literally no taste. We grabbed Parmesan, red pepper and salt and pepper and threw everything we could onto this pizza to try to evoke something equivalent to Margheritas we have had in the past. We are ever so grateful you are trying to offer us an option but I implore you, keep shopping for a crust that actually has a semblance of a real pizza. They are out there and are quite great. We spent (with the GF crust up charge) $18 for the pizza in the pictures. That is sad. We decided then and there this would not be a repeat. Please let us know if you bring in a crust that actually doesn’t make a GF person want to cry."

"Best meal I've had in nearly 2 years. Following a covid infection, my taste and smell came back warped. I've stopped going out to restaurants because food generally feels like a trap. Having the ability to choose ALL my own ingredients made a huge difference! So yeah, very first meal I've truly enjoyed in what feels like an eternity. **Plus, the presentation was gorgeous. Salad in a wheat bread bowl:"

"I’ve been to a few Your Pie locations and this one definitely lived up to the hype. The staff was super friendly to my 2 year old daughter and helpful! We asked for a separate container of black olives bc I’m not a fan of them but my wife and daughter love them, and they gave us several scoops worth! The pizza was fresh, hot and delicious, beer was cold, and the interior is really clean and welcoming. Loved it!"

"It is always so yummy. The people who work there are nice and fun they gave my son a ball of dough to play with. The gelato is so creamy and there are plenty of flavors. I describe it to those I met and tell them it is gourmet pizza for fast food prices. They have a wide range of toppings that you can get as much as you want. They offer gluten free and vegan options so it is a place for all."