New York City Pizza 107 Towne Drive, Bluffton, SC 29910

"My review is primarily focused on their ability to handle a party of 15 with an advanced reservation, which primarily ordered dinners. Despite the fact that their website touts they can handle parties of up to 70, they were overwhelmed. From the bar to the kitchen it was extremely disappointing. The only thing served in a timely fashion was a salad and 1 pizza. BTW, the rest of the restaurant was not busy at all. What irritated me the most was what appeared to be a woman manager, basically sitting at the bar the entire time offering little or no help to the overwhelmed staff. The chick marsala was good, the remainder of the dishes, served one by one over an hour or more, were at best fair. For dessert we wanted to order cannolis. They had only one for us to split. If you wish to dine there, keep it simple, pizza and beer."

"This was one of our favorite local lunch spots, but the staff changed, so we started going on different days to hopefully get the better staff. The last time we visited was the last time I will ever visit. The server was not only rude, but nasty to another diner nearby. The food is overpriced and mediocre."

"Staff was attentive and nice. I had to wait a little bit for my takeout and they kept me updated and kept checking on it. Turns out I had to wait for the slices because they made a fresh pizza. It tasted phenomenal!"

"The food and service is really good. Pizza tastes like what I use to eat in Long Island. Plus the young blond waitress makes the best Long Island Tea I have ever had! Sorry that I don’t remember her name, but she has been working at the Buckwalter location since they opened. She took a picture of me and my friend last week when we had lunch there. I recommend New York Pizza. Miriam T."

"Let me first start by saying I don't live here and only came here in hopes of grabbing a few slices of pizza after a long shopping trip at Home Depot. Walked inside and was greeted by a lady who said 2, I said no we're not eating there but I wanted to know if you sell pizza by the slice. She said yes, handed me a menu and said all of the pizzas with red sauce are by the slice. I ordered 6 slices of pizza and she told me the total, I handed her my card without even thinking and paid. She said it would be about 10 min and she walked away. My daughter was with me and said mom, how did you just pay $49 for 6 slices of pizza. It then hit me. I said wait, slices of pizza are 3.50 per slice. When the lady came back over to where I was I said excuse me, I think the register charged me twice for everything. She quickly and rudly said no, there are extra charges for every topping you added to the pizza. I was instantly irritated and disappointed! Why in the world would any person, better yet employee allow someone to pay 49.00 for 6 slices of pizza when an entire 16" pizza costs $32.00. Just reliving this infuriates me. How incredibly ignorant! And mind you, when she said pizza is available by the slice only for red sauce pizzas she NEVER said, but all toppings are extra money. When we got into the car less than 2 min after receiving the pizza and started eating it, the pizza was cold, the topping were cold and the veggies were raw. I lifted the pizza and it appeared to have no crust under the pizza from the middle to the end. All in all very disappointing and guarantee I'll never be back. I requested through the website for someone to contact me which has yet to happen."