East Islip Jewelers

"Watch sellers beware and don’t waste your time: 10 year Buyer and seller here with my own location— Gerson ‘the watchmaker’ starts chewing my Rolex on the PHONE over ‘diamonds’ which makes no sense because the original factory parts are included, also makes even less sense: before seeing a picture or knowing the information, condition, didn’t ask if it was a full set, full links, the source etc. Gerson starts immediately negating the watch because of the F VVS diamond bezel that’s listed $4000 and dial is a $2800 part anywhere. Mind that I INCLUDE the ORIGINAL FACTORY PARTS as a bonus— the watch could be back to original with swapping out the diamond dial and bezel in 10 minutes, then they can even sell the parts separately online: diamond dial $2000 on eBay and the bezel for $3000, thus beating everyone on there by $1000. I was just MATCHING the OFFER I got in DIAMOND DISTRICT and trying to save the trip. Once again — this guy does not know the correct questions to ask, just tunnel vision to get the lowest priced item, in turn blowing the deal for the owner because he didn’t even collect the information in its entirety. Don’t waste your time. Probably a guy that changes batteries and removes stones from scrap."

"I came in to have a wristband size adjusted for 1 watch and a battery replaced on another watch. The young lady who assisted me did a great job. And the service was completed quickly,"

"Mr G was completely courteous and helpful and so was the staff. I had a lot of old jewelry from many years past. He was honest with me and gave me a fair price for my gold. I will definitely recommend East Islip Jewelers to all my friends who might be looking to either sell gold or take old engagement ring settings and turn them into something new and exciting."

"I came here based on the great reviews I saw online. This was by far, the most pleasant experience I've ever had at any jeweler I've ever been to. They fixed a small stone in a wedding band and sold a gold necklace. From start to finish, it was an excellent experience. Pricing for jewelry repair is reasonable. I did not even have to come back for my wedding band to be fixed - they fixed on the spot within less than 5 minutes. The whole process - I was in and out of there in 10 minutes. The guy who helped me was so friendly and helpful. I will definitely be back, as I have more jewelry repairs."

"My experience at East Islip Jewelers was beyond excellent! Based on my vision, Mr. G designed a beautiful stone necklace that I will love for years. If you are looking for someone to bring your design vision into reality, Mr. G is the man to see! Joann also helped me pick a ring and some earrings that are perfect for me. Her expertise and sense of style are greatly appreciated - I am so excited to wear my new jewelry. Thank you East Islip, I will be back!"