Nolan's on Canandaigua Lake

"I had a lovely birthday dinner! Service was great and my food was top notch as well. I had the NY Strip, seasoned well, and cooked to medium rare perfection. My baked potato was fluffy inside and the skin was salted and had the tiniest bit of crisp. The onion rings that came with the plate were good too-- super crisp on the outside, with onion inside cooked, but not cooked to mush like most places. This will sound weird, but I also noticed the glassware was all absolutely SPARKLING. Great place to celebrate."

"Went for dinner on a Saturday early evening for our anniversary. Made reservations with Open Table which I highly recommend. Our wait was less than 5 minutes from arriving. We were waited on very quickly. Katia was our waitress. She was truly the greatest. Every recommendation she gave us was spot on AMAZING. From the drinks to food everything was cooked/made to perfection. We were so impressed with the service and how delicious the food was. We will definitely be back. We thought it was sweet of them to add the happy anniversary sign and then decorating our desert plate. It really was a sweet touch to an already perfect dining experience."

"We had the scallops as a starter. They were absolutely delectable. I ordered the pork chops with sweet potato fries. The sweet potato fries were delicious. I could have had more! First of all, the pork chop was burnt and way too salty. But even worse, almost halfway, we realized the pork was rotten. It was so pungent that I couldn't eat and in fact returned it. Although they omitted it from the bill, be warned! My friend had the captain Pete's fish and chips which he absolutely loved. The wine and service were great. The place was a bit too crowded (we got there at about 8pm on a Saturday). If you like spicy food, you'll appreciate that they brought two kinds - Cajun and red pepper flakes."

"Another fabulous meal. My lady had the scallops, and I had one of the best lobster rolls I have ever had. For starters, the garlic bread is so rich and flavorful with the cheeses and fresh marinara. Service was as good as the food! Will keep coming back!"

"5+ stars for service. Amazing staff! Went on a busy Friday evening for dinner with kids. Lobster pasta was delicious!! Steak was medium well inside as requested but was overcooked on outside. Calamari undercooked inside was a bit tough to chew so didn't have much. Dining experience with the fantastic staff is just perfect for family so would absolutely recommend!"