La Focaccia

"I have been going to this pizzeria for over 10 years. The pizza has remained very solid. Ingredients are fresh, the sauce is tasty with a hint of sweetness but not overly sweet and the crust is always crispy and tasty. On of the better regular slices in the Melville area for sure. That said, they have come down in quality over the years. This was a five star pizzeria before covid. Since then the quality has noticeably dropped, as has the service. They used to be very personable counter people and now you walk in and they act like they are doing you a favor to serve you. Also very limiting seating and very tight and uncomfortable seating arrangements. The tables are literally less than a foot apart. So for pizza it’s still solid but don’t go for service or ambiance. Also their parking lot is a disaster. Extremely limited and Ive see. several near accidents. Not entirely their fault as they share the lot with a few other stores but just another frustrating thing about gojng there. You literally have to park on a very dangerous and busy main road (route 110) to get your food."

"The BEST Italian food around! We order food from here every week and it never disappoints. Very accommodating too! The owner, manager and Bridget are all so nice. The owner treats his customers like family. Highly recommend!"

"Drove in from Florida yesterday, first stop was our hotel, second stop was La Focaccia cause I needed authentic NY pizza after a combined 26 hour road trip through hell and high water up the entire east coast of America and I gotta say they did not disappoint, the pizza was large and juicy and delicious, the wings were fried to perfection, but mostly the guys behind the counter were consummate pizza pros who were tickled that we chose their store as our first destination after getting settled. I will definitely be going back later in the week for a grandma slice and some knots, 5 stars all around."

"Stopped in for takeout for the drive back to NJ. 2 slices & 2 drinks cost $17.83! The CBR slice was great, multiple cheeses, grilled chicken, roasted tomatoes, slightly burned crust. Spinach artichoke was good the first bite, sadly everything following was like eating a melted butter/breadcrumb soup, very heavy. Had to wait to order and to pay despite being the only one in line."

"By far my favorite pizza place I've been to. I'm fairly picky with pizza, but I always go here when I'm working in the area. I got a slice of Buffalo and a slice of sweet chili chicken. Came to almost $12 but it was well worth it. They have a wide variety of slices and other options."