17A Cafe

"Excellent cafe with super fresh food and great atmosphere. All the salads are made from scratch and even the lox is hand-sliced each day. You can really taste the difference and the whole store is clean and inviting. The owner was so friendly and helpful. Definitely recommend!"

"Scott was great!!! He was friendly, personable and gave me a break on my order of 2 lobster roll sandwiches i had ordered for a day trip to fire island with my Momma. They were both made with care with lots of chunks of lobster and super delicious too!!! The highlight of our day trip was the super lunch Scott prepared for us. I highly recommend going here as the service and food quality is off the charts!! Thanks again Scott u made my 91 years young Momma & I very happy with those sandwiches!!!"

"Went there for a coffee and muffin but was pleasantly welcomed by Scotty Bagel the owner. The place is tiny but packed with goodies. I asked Scotty to make me a nice breakfast and he proceeded to making a sampler of 4 of his smoked salmons on a scooped out everything bagel cut in four quarters with scallion cream cheese, tomatoes, onions and squeezed lime. OUT OF THIS WORLD. To my delight he also has flavored creamers for my coffee. And he made everything with care and LOVE. Great experience. As I was leaving he said if I call my order beforehand he’ll have it ready for pickup so I wouldn’t have to wait next time. This is one place I would 100% trust to make my order to perfection."

"Best açaí bowls on Long Island! Lobster medley salad is so fresh and delicious. Smoked fish also excellent. Lots of vegan and gluten free options as well. Awesome cafe!!"