Old Orchard Tavern

"I will keep some details of my visit between myself and the restaurant management, but my overall rating is true. The food was really tasty and great for presentation, quality, and quantity for the amount paid. The service was also good and attentive. Our food arrived quickly and was 100% correct the way we asked for it the first time with no issues. For two people who had the steak specials and water, it was $75~ before tip. It was not the worst amount spent in a restaurant but certainly could improve in some areas to justify the cost. Yes, as others have said, the restaurant could stand to use a little sprucing or modernization, but do you really go to a restaurant to look at the walls, floors, and ceilings anyway? The food was excellent."

"We had a wedding party that was reserved. The entire experience was painful. They didn't have enough staff, one brand new server- her very first night there and the only server there ( who was amazingly kind and accommodating). We ordered food took an hour and a half to recieve, and all of the food was not palatable. It's very unfortunate because the experience we had 2 years ago was amazing and the steaks were out of this world- that is why we all came back. Never again will I go there. Very very disappointed and dissatisfied. The steaks were rubbery, bloody and disgusting, the Mac and cheese looked like out of kraft box with a slice of cheese on top. The nachos were dry and cold, I could go on and on but no need. We got there at 6:30pm didn't leave til 10 pm thats how long it took to be served and given bill. Normally we are the kind of family that would speak up immediately but it was so exhausting watching the server go back and forth and how long we waited we just decided to suck up the overly priced dinners and keep quiet. They were very nice to give my niece and her husband complimentary champagne for their wedding celebration and that was appreciated but please take your customers advice and get some new cooks and better food. Thank you"

"If I could give zero, I would. Waited 30 minutes for the first drink. Bartender, Rich, keeps skipping over my husband and myself to wait on other guests. Moved to the patio where we asked Dee for a food menu and a second beer (canned because all drafts were out). Dee never returned. An hour later, we went to the bar where Rich looked at us then helped multiple other people. 2 hours and we were unable to order any of the overpriced food. Tried reaching out to management but the website doesn't work. I sent a FB message with no reply. This was 3 days ago. I will never go back."

"Hidden gem. This place has the best Prime Rib. They give you extremely large portions and each and every bite is spectacular! Here's what I wonder. I wonder if the staff knows what's coming and they are so used to people's reactions when they bring out this ginormous plate of food that are just very nonchalant about it. It's enough food that I thought I was in an eating competition. You cannot go wrong if you eat here."

"Do not be fooled by the location... this place is a 5 star restaurant all the way ! the pork and Apple slaw was amazing ,my prime rib was to die for !!amazing service from Peter who knew the menu well. And even great pizza would actually be back again"