Peachtree Suites

"The room even if it looked pretty new it wasn't clean and the smell of smoke/cigarette at the arrival was unbearable, the sofa especially smelled like a giant ashtray. The temperature of the water in the bathroom does not go beyond lukewarm and air conditioning didn't work. Having said that, the guys at the reception are very nice and welcoming. The location is ok because of its close distance to the Path station of Journal Square, but in the surroundings there's pretty much nothing to do. Honestly I wouldn't come back."

"Convenient location especially if you don’t want to drive into the city but enjoy driving yourself there! Subway and parking nearby. As well as Starbucks. We didn’t really spend much time nearby. The hotel itself is small. The rooms were up to date, clean. Our only issue is noise from the lobby area/1st floor. Also went to check out , then there was no one to be found. I would return but ask for a room on another floor . Would suggest soda/snack areas , coffee for your guests (for purchase)"

"I like cooking. The kitchen was a neat addition. I tried cleaning up after myself but my boyfriend was a huge distraction. Thank you for your hospitality and for making our stay comfortable. The room was clean and orderly and the locks made me feel safe. The last hotel we stayed at, my boyfriend almost got shot by a man who hadn't vacated the room we were assigned. All me and my boyfriend wanted was to spend time together and that gunman was the last thing we needed."

"The only reason I gave it 4 stars was because the location is very noisy, but that is not the owner’s fault. Otherwise, it’s definitely a 5.Hallways were very quiet; we never heard another guest. Room was newly redecorated, very clean, and had great new appliances— spacious refrigerator, full stove, microwave, dishwasher, toaster, coffee machine with supplies, and even a hot water pot for tea. Bed and sofa bed very comfy with plenty of extra pillows. The lobby is locked ( you enter with a code) and there is no one there at night( owner/ manager lives next door and can be contacted by phone.) We arrived late and had to phone him; he came right over, was very welcoming, stayed til we were settled, and even came up to the room to show us how to lock the balcony door. He was friendly and attentive. We loved that transportation was close and reliable( PATH trains to NYC a short walk away and busses right at the next street.) Lots of good Indian restaurants ( and others) within walking distance. We will stay again."

"On the 28th March 2023 we booked a 5-night stay. We booked a Queen Deluxe Suite for our family. We paid special attention to the amenities that came with this suite and was particularly impressed with the fact that the room came with a balcony, a tub in the bathroom and a fully fitted kitchenette. It was also advertised as being sound proof. We were given a room that was street level so there was no balcony just a small dank and dark outside space. The room had virtually no natural light so we always had to have the lights turned on. The room did not have a bath tub - just a wet room with a shower. The room was not soundproofed at all. As we were on the ground floor, we heard everyone leaving and entering the hotel, going up and down in the lift, as well as having conversations in the corridor and foyer at all times of the day and night. There was music playing constantly in the foyer which we had to ask to be turned off every evening in order for my son to be able to sleep. We could hear the noise of the traffic throughout the night. There was no safety deposit - so we had to carry our valuables with us all the time. The utensils, crockery, and cutlery provided in the kitchenette were appalling. The plates were mismatched, the knives and forks were sparse. There were no cooking/oven trays - plus no basic everyday kitchenware. It was abysmal. There was no dining table as advertised just a desk with one chair. Our son had to eat at the table, and we had to eat on our laps. The following day, we reported our concerns to the front desk and were told that another room would be available the next day. We were told to pack our belongings and asked to wait for 3hrs. The room that we were offered was not a Queen Deluxe Studio but as we later discovered, a Standard Studio. It was much smaller, had a smaller sofa bed which would not have been appropriate for our teenage son. It was also in a state of disrepair - exposed wires and scuffed walls. We had no choice but to refuse the sub-standard room so then had to spend time again unpacking. When we were leaving, we expressed how disappointed we were with our stay and pointed out all of the above to the front desk. We also made it clear that we felt that no solutions had been offered to try and resolve our concerns. The reaction of the member of staff was 'lukewarm' disinterest. We wrote a very detailed email to the company describing our experience asked for a refund due to us not receiving what we had booked and they point blank refused to engage with us. We were very, very disappointed in the accommodation and the attitude of the staff and owner – we’re not sure if this is because they have an issue with either our gender or race. WE STRONGLY ENCOURAGE YOU NOT TO BOOK TO STAY AT THIS HOTEL."