Sally Boy's Pizza

"I'm sorry, this was a very bad experience buying salads at the new place that just opened here. This salad went straight to garbage, awful. It should not cost $18 for food that was thrown out. I'd expect to have much better food at this place. I may never try ordering anything here again unless someone tell me they enjoyed it. It's just bad. A pre-made, soaked in vinegar large chunks of lettuce, dried out chicken pieces and olives. This is not even close to nice salad. Learn to make salads or change the chef."

"Made the Journey from our Home in Manchester, NJ for "Pi Day" to visit Sally Boy's Pizza on the Southeast corner of the Broad Street & East Front Street in Red Bank, NJ... Both Kit and I decided on the Sally Boy Slice which is a 8" Personal Pizza for $8.00, we each added 2 toppings which added $3.00 for each pie. Kit had Bacon and Onions and I chose Pepperoni and Sausage... The pie is cut into 4 slices, the dough has a pleasant taste but has a rubbery textured with a very significant New York Flop that was easily corrected with the New Jersey Fold... The ingredients, cheese, sauce and the other toppings were Top Notch, the sauce was sweet with a little bite and the cheese was not greasy!!! We decided to have something else to see how they tasted. Kit had 4 Cheese, Rice Balls with very tasty Tomato Dipping Sauce... I chose a Pepperoni Focaccia Slice. The slice was more of a slice with substance and a pleasing taste... I would recommend other's to have a slice from under the glass reheated, it is a better bargain and more of a meal. Will have to stop by again and order a larger - full size pizza to see how that compares with other pizza joint's in the area."

"A really good place with a really good vibe. The sauce is really good. The pizza, in my opinion, is a little thick. I hope they will make it a little thinner. Either way I will come back because it tastes great. I can't wait to try more of what they have! The new spot for my and my friends!"

"Offer 12” and 16” pies made to order. Prices are a little high because in my world, 2 people get 2 - 12” pies to share. Margherita pie was amazing as was the vodka pie. Cannoli and rainbow cakes also great! They’re new and still shaking out some details so be patient they are trying their best. Although, this is about to be a chain across the US and the owners should have shaken out the details in advance.. On arguably the most important corner of Red Bank, I hate that some non local guy came in to add yet another Italian place to the mix however, this place is GOOD and you can tell Jeremy the manager is knowledgeable and cares!! And we will all be using the late night window. Will be back ASAP!"

"Absolutely delicious! The food amazing hot fresh and so good! The staff all so happy and pleased to be there. Very polite and helpful. Ryan/Ronnie? I’m sorry I can’t remember was amazing and so nice he even threw a freebie of slices of Napoleon’s in our takeout bag! We got a large plain pie, sausage and pepper roll and a spinach roll. We also bought the rainbow cookies. All far surpassed my expectations, I’ve been waiting so long for this establishment to open! I work in red bank so I will be visiting and eating here very often. And my husband and I spend weekends shopping in red bank so we will be sure to stop by for our next date night. Welcome to the Neighborhood Sally Boys so happy you’re here!!!!"