Tenafly Pizza Restaurant 38 West Railroad Avenue, Tenafly, NJ 07670

"Food,service and atmosphere are great! Been coming here quite often. Some of the reviews are truly entertaining on this site. If you eat pizza from a gas station you should be disqualified from reviewing any type of food, period! Red flag…."

"Excellent pizza and Italian selections at moderate pricing. Warm bread delivered to the table as they bring your menus. The portions are generous. Our table of three had the Plain and Margherita personal size pizzas and a huge meatball sandwich. Also, we shared a large and tasty romaine house salad. Nice white tablecloth atmosphere with a selection of booths and tables. The entrance to the sit-down section of the restaurant is not obvious. It's through the door off to your left as you enter the take-out portion of the restaurant. Nice dining for what is essentially a strip mall restaurant."

"Great food, Amazing Service. Hands down the best restaurant in town. I was shocked to see that some people left a negative review. I would question the legitimacy of those individuals and reviews."

"I have been going here for over 25 years. it’s under new management; the waiter (not his fault) didn’t give me bread for my table because I didn’t order an entree. Mind you we ordered a large pie, soup, chicken fingers and fries with 3 sodas. I like to have my bread with soup! I was totally shocked. I don’t think I’ll be returning sadly. Also owners should wait for there to be no customers before spray painting furniture it was uncomfortable to smell as it was being done in booth next to me. I did asked to be moved. But the not giving me bread blew me away."

"Tenafly Pizza is a popular pizzeria known for its delicious, authentic New York-style pizzas. The restaurant uses high-quality ingredients and traditional recipes to create its pies, which are cooked in a wood-fired oven to give them a crisp, lightly charred crust. In addition to its classic pizzas, Tenafly Pizza also offers a variety of specialty pies, as well as salads, subs, calzones, and other Italian favorites. Many customers appreciate the restaurant's friendly and accommodating staff, as well as its casual, laid-back atmosphere. We tried dinner grilled chicken, dinner grilled shrimp, lobster tail, and large cheese pizza. We enjoy the food and the atmosphere."