Comet Pizza 1288 North Broad Street, Hillside, NJ 07205

"Needless to say the service and quality has changed with the new ownership. The pizza is not bad but definitely not like the original Comet’s pizza. Also, the ONLY time service is good there is when the gentleman owner is there; because every time I’ve called or gone and he’s not there the woman is so rude. Called to ask for 2 slices to go pick up within a few minutes (like 5) for my work lunch and the lady had an attitude. I asked to put an order in for the slices and her response was “You can.”(sarcastically) “But we’re not allowed to put the slices in until you get here, so.” So why not just say that new policy is you can no longer do that? Also, this never used to be an issue."

"I don't know what they put in that pizza but it's just awesome. I go there every day after work for a buffalo chicken slice(it's kind of a ritual for me), and it hits the spot every time. I tried asking if they were on uber eats but it seems they haven't taken that step yet. Then the manager told me it's because they do their own deliveries and I figured out why their pizzas are just a little pricey(see picture). It's free delivery!!! Of course they have to charge more they need to pay the delivery guy. Kudos for being one of the only few businesses with that kind of fair practice. It's a new owner but I'd only wish they would open on sundays as that's cheat day for me and my family and I'm sure there's a whole bunch more out there wishing the same I'm sure... that and the amount of pizzas they would have roll out daily if they were on uber eats or grubhub. But maybe the demand would be too great idk... Oh well, wish you fellas the best and thanks for providing such an amazing service, clean and cozy atmosphere, and the best pizza I've ever had. And coming from me that's something, I order pizza from almost every pizza joint out there, this one beats them all."

"A short Uber ride from our airport hotel at Newark we stumbled upon Comet Pizza. A stupendous place for a pie. Awesome pie, awesome people, definitely try the mozzarella log, absolutely to die for, all of it! Super friendly owners, give you that at home eating in your own kitchen feel. I'm tempted to make a special trip back to Newark just to have another comet pizza pie. My kind of place."