Black Forest Inn

"Since 1977, three generations of the Aichem family have worked at this establishment over the decades. Black Forest Inn, located in Stanhope, is a diamond in the rough, as it’s far and few for German cuisine in New Jersey. Upon arrival, its beautiful old-world stonework and rustic wood décor welcomed us for dinner as first-timers, which a number of our friends had recommended. Reservations were easily made through Yelp. Upon entering, it felt like I was back in Bavaria with the warm, German-themed vibe featuring eye-catching outdoor paintings, lively beer steins lining the walls, and stained glass hunting scenes. Warmly welcomed by the host and owner, Barbara, my partner and I were seated promptly in one of the multi-dining rooms. Our server, Melissa, dressed in authentic Dirndls clothing as we made small talk. The German and European fusion menus with excellent farm-to-table include seasonal favorites, extensive daily specialties with on- and off-premise catering, and takeouts. As appetizers, we decided on the potato pancakes with apple sauce and sour cream as well as the pretzel sticks with the house-made beer cheese sauce. For our main meal, we opted for the Traditional Wienerschnitzel (thin, breaded, pan-fried veal cutlet) Black Forest accompanied with Spätzle (egg noodles) and Red Cabbage, as well as Chicken Breast Jager with Wine Mushroom Cream Sauce served with Spätzle and Carrots. Complimentary bread with butter started our meal, which we downed with Radler (half beer and half lemon soda). The finest and freshest ingredients are presented with simple elegance to every meal. From appetizers to the main courses, the food was beyond expectations. The portions were huge, and we guaranteed you would not leave hungry. Prices were not outrageous. The atmosphere, the service, and the food make this restaurant worth the 40-minute drive, which we can recommend."

"A lovely experience overall. Because of our lack of experience and knowledge in authentic German cuisine, my family and I bombarded the waitress with an arsenal of questions. However, all of our questions were thoughtfully and patiently answered by the kind waitress, and we were met with a plethora of delicious food that was incredibly satisfying to the mouth. Along with the lovely food, the interior of this restaurant is a treat to the eyes. Thank you~!"

"So good. Crystal, our server, was awesome. Will come back soon. Best to reserve a table if you come with a party of more than 4 people"