Papa Mario's Pizza 519 South Black Horse Pike, Haddon Heights, NJ 08035

"I took a chance ordering from here while staying at a hotel up the street and let me just say WOW! I ordered a small Stromboli which has sausage, pepperoni and mozz cheese with a 4oz side of sauce. The menu I had said 11.99 but I guess they charge a delivery fee because it came to $16 plus another few bucks for a tip. Delivery was fast and the driver was courteous and friendly. I asked for a few paper plates which were provided along with napkins. I’ll admit when I first opened the box I was a bit underwhelmed with the size, even though I ordered a small it was pretty small for a $20 Stromboli. My initial disappointment was immediately gone once I took a piece (I liked that they sliced it into 4 slices) and dipped it into their sauce and took a bite. It was packed with pepperoni, delicious Italian sausage (not that pork crumble ball crap but real sliced Italian sausage) and delicious grande mozzarella cheese! Their red sauce was probably one of the best I’ve tasted in a very long time. It was cooked perfectly to a shiny golden brown (they must egg wash it). I couldn’t stop eating it and didn’t leave a crumb behind. If the rest of their food is even half as good you’ll be happy you ordered from here. It was worth every penny even with tip and delivery fee but in the future I’ll save the extra $6-7 and pick it up. I wish I had stopped for half a second to take a picture for everyone but I’ll add one next time I get one which I’m sure will be soon. Edit 1/26/24 - So, it’s only been a couple days and I couldn’t resist trying their pizza! I ordered a thick crust Sicilian with 1/2-sausage for pickup. Let me just say it did not disappoint in the least bit, 16 thick slices of absolute heaven! It was cooked perfectly, the sauce was just as tasty as it was with the Stromboli, the thick slices of fennel laced Italian sausage are delicious (could’ve used a few more slices but the quality makes up for it and I’m just a huge fan of sausage so I can always use more!) and the grande mozz cheese is creamy, stretchy and delicious, and this thick crust is light-airy and not greasy. It’s been a long time since I’ve had a Sicilian pizza this good. I’ll be moving next week but you can bet that anytime I’m in the area that this will be my go to pizzeria. You’ll be hard pressed to find a better pizza or Stromboli in the area (I know I’ve tried quite a few and none compared)!"

"Pizza is first class, perfect under carriage, crust has the crunch I always long for. Mike is the best, guaranteed he will deliver with A+ pie! Great wings too!"

"Cannot say enough wonderful things about both the owner, Rock, and the food! I met with the owner Thursday afternoon to discuss catering my daughter's birthday party (last minute change in plans left me scrambling for a replacement) I tried some food (that he ultimately let me have free of charge) and also threw in some fresh Buffalo wings to-go, which were amazing. After discussing the food I wanted, he was willing to drop pricing below his standard, to the budget I had for the food... but because of his amazing care *and delicious food* I simply told him I would pay the extra couple dollars! And let me tell you, it was well worth it. The food was fresh, delicious, and HOT. He even threw in a few condiments and an extra side of cheese that I annoyingly asked for the morning of, free of charge. Overall this is a place we will be using for our family events going forward. Food is delicious and customer service is top-notch... oh, and the biggest/ most impressive part? They accommodated us Thursday evening for a pick-up Saturday afternoon. So less than 48 hour notice. Give this place your business, and you WON'T be disappointed."

"Driving down from Maine back home to Florida I knew my fiancé wanted a Tomato Pie. Papa Mario’s did not disappoint! The sauce was amazing and he was so happy! The staff was so nice. We even chatted football GO PHILLY! If you want an amazing pie this is the place."

"My visit to Papa Mario’s was A very nice experience, they were very friendly and helpful. The establishment was very clean and organized , plus with the holiday decorations created a warm feeling of Christmas. They have a very nice size flatscreen TV on the wall in their dining area for enjoying every moment of the game. The pizza was delicious and I highly recommend trying the old style pizza from Papa Mario’s. It’s so good! …..Keep up the good work guys, you are on the right track! ."