Sorrento Gourmet Pizza

"I always get takeout at the place but it never fails to produce great pizza and Italian dishes. The pizza crust is unique whether thin crust or regular. The owner is welcoming and a pleasure to deal with (Plus his name is Rudy so you can't go wrong)"

"Ordered a classic cheese pie on a recent work trip while staying nearby. Just OK. Soft and doughy crust, no firmness or crunch. Weird sauce/cheese/crust ratio, causing cheese to slide off when biting even after letting it sit for a little while to make sure it sets. The sauce flavor itself is good. The cheese is not and seems bland and/or frozen. The pie was just not put together too well. Not horrible but you should be able to find much better in this area of NY. Service was prompt. We ordered a large pie for 2 people who would usually eat the entire thing between us, and we threw it out after 4 slices."

"Great old school pizza made the way it should be. Thin crust cooked to perfection. Semolina dusting on the crust. Authentic Bronx/Brooklyn pizza. I am a pizza snob. This place nails it! Awesome. Best in the area!"

"We ordered a pizza from Sorrento's during the week in the afternoon, in August 2023. We were told that they were very good by our local relatives. So we ordered a pizza to go. I will keep this review to the food itself, as I didn't go in for the pie. The crust was decent. But the pie itself was a little dry with no oil or such. But it wasn't bad. But I will say that I did not find it all that great either. Although it was much better than the last pizza we ordered elsewhere recently. So the hype we heard didn't live up to the expectation. Again, it wasn't bad, but not all that great either. Yes, I would eat it again if the opportunity was there. But I would try another pizza from somewhere else first, if it was my call."

"PIZZA LOVERS MUST VISIT! I am from Brooklyn NY and pizza is EVERYTHING! My husband and I were in Goshen and had a quick pit stop here for a bite. Can I say that I am in love with their pizza! The crust was super crispy on the outside and just the right thickness with super yummy sauce and cheese (that was not oily!). I loved, loved, loved the pizza! Definitely visiting again!"