Mama's Cafe Baci

"What a grand welcome we received upon entering your restaurant. This was our first time at Mama’s and my family and I enjoyed your hospitality. Three members of our table had Dairy and/or Gluten allergies. The owner, Tomasso, personally came to our table and went over the menu, and the amazing variety of dishes that you make with fresh ingredients to each customers personal order. Thank you for this experience and for the delicious food and service you and your staff gave us. We will be back! The Burke Family from Vernon Township, NJ visited in February 3, 2024"

"1st time I visited: Service was amazing.. the chef/owner was very warm and friendly gentleman. He explained to us the different menus and the history of the restaurant. I am dairy free and 2 people in my party were gluten free and dairy free. I’ve never seen such a complex menu with endless options for dairy free/gluten free people. Its been 10+ years since I’ve had a chicken parm or any type of cheesecake dessert. Mama’s made it possible."

"One of 3 restaurants in Hackettstown that deserve to be considered local institutions (the other two being the Sub Shack & Hong Kong Palace). Mamma’s is Warren county’s best and most storied Italian restaurant and pizzeria, and for good reason. Everything here is expertly crafted authentic Italian American home cooking, from their popular pasta/entree duet plates to of course their calling card, their NY/NJ style pies featuring some of the best sauce I’ve had on a pizza. That’s on top of having some of the friendliest customer service around. not to mention, I’m pretty sure the owners know my dad‘s family. If they’re reading this, my dad’s name is Mike Gerola, but they probably know him as Tyke since that’s his nickname around town."

"Pretty regular customer and the food and service is normally great. However, got quick take out last night. 5 slices. 3 Sicilian and 2 regular. Pizza was in box taped shut upon pickup, and didn't think to open to check. Had I done that before driving 20min home I would've said something. Pics explain it all. The Sicilian slices were thin and smaller than acceptable from such a normally great establishment. I'll chalk it up to being a Wednesday evening anomaly, but several eyes had to see this before it went out door."

"I booked the Coach Room for my 60th Birthday on October 21st. I corresponded with Sheri, from Mama's, for a number of weeks before the event and she was amazing and listening to and dealing with all my concerns, especially in regards to my guests' dietary needs as well as my own. She went above and beyond to make my party perfect. The staff at the Coach Room were so attentive and the service fantastic. The food was fabulous and the space beautifully decorated."