Fatboy's Pizza Shack

"The reason for the bad review is the owner. 13 years ago when the restaurant opened...my friends and I chatted up with the owner. At one point, he mentioned that the Holocaust was staged. A Holocaust denier. He may deny saying that and I have no proof. Or may have changed his views. But as adamant as he was, I am guessing, he has not changed much. So, hence my poor review. Call me a hater, smear my name but I know my truth."

"The pizza was to have 5 free toppings on a large pizza. Toppings chosen were green peppers, ham, pepperoni, bacon, sausage, onions, and extra cheese. All toppings were skimpy, especially the bacon and the extra cheese. I paid extra for the 2 extra toppings. Plus, the sauce wasn't sweet like we like. And it was better when U could eat in. There was no one in the place where U figure out how to get out of the maze game. The guy was nice and carried my pizza to my car since I had trouble walking. I had asked him to carry it out. Thanks for that."

"Delicious pizza and wedges. Highly recommend the steak wedge. Chicken Parm wedge was 3/5 but steak was 5/5! 3 wedges was sufficient to split between 2 adults Friendly staff, offers outdoor dining with a nice view."

"Get on the western Maryland railroad from Cumberland to Frostburg. When you get to Frostburg, make the 5-minute walk up to Fatboy’s. It will be worth it. Good food. Good people. 3 of 5 on atmosphere because it was the middle of the day on a Saturday. Food is standard pizzeria fare, but very good. Good selection of drinks. Some good home made cookies and brownies. “These are SO GOOD,” was all my five year old could say. She didn’t leave any to take back home to mom. That’s how you know it’s good. Owners are clearly Christian, but the good kind. Not pushy. Served people from different walks of life while we were there."

"Use to get pizza. This time I got a steak wedge and it was fantastic! Lots of meat, very flavorful, I would recommend it. Great price too. Ate here again, got a Supreme pizza and a 20 ounce drink for less than 6 bucks. Pizza was really good. Update May 2023 : This time I got winds. They are amazing. $10.00 for 12 wings? Nobody has a deal like that!! And they are amazing! Not overcooked, great flavors, I cant believe how good they are!! I've tried two flavors and both were great! Plus, they are vey nice people as well. Not required but a nice bonus."