The Elmton

"Being from out of town, we were looking for a good place for dinner & The Elmton was referred to us by a friend. We couldn't find anything bad about the place. Some of the best pizzas we ever had, Both styles of pizza were very good, but the thicker one edged out the thinner version for us. Both were almost equally amazing. I usually have photos, but unfortunately, on this trip, I took them on snapchat & forgot to save them. I don't think you can go wrong with any of the food served here. Everything we saw coming out to the other tables looked amazing!"

"We order take out from the Elmton several times a month. The hot roast beef dinner is glorious! Reminds of the food I grew up on."

"We had a large group, about 14 people, and the server was great! They were pretty busy but our food came at a reasonable time. The pizza is excellent, and I wish we had one closer to our location!"

"This was my first time dining in. I've only ever gotten carry out in the past. It's a nice place and the staff is so friendly and so funny. I did try to broasted chicken for the first time and it was good but nothing beats their pizza."

"A staple for the greater Youngstown area. We always come here when we come home to visit family. Absolutely love this place and so happy that that dinning room is back open. The bar is absolutely a beautiful piece of vintage hardwood and creates a complete feel to the entire interior. I get so happy coming here. Thinking of all the generations that sat here before me. Can't say any one thing is better than the other. If you want the authentic experience and you have not been here before don't just get a slice that has been made already. Get a fresh made to order Pizza and note that if you get toppings on your pizza that it will take away for the authentic real flavor of the pizza just as a cheese pizza. This is how you can tell pizza from others is the sauce and cheese. The restaurant gets busy so have patience. For the full experience go alone. Sit at the bar and get a beer and broasted chicken or fish. Their sandwiches are incredible. Roast Beef is a favorite. Remember good food takes time and it's well worth the wait."