Buffy's Ice Cream & Cafe 456 Main Street, Chatham, MA 026633

"Pink Explosion! My daughter dove into a strawberry ice cream and pink sprinkle cup of deliciousness! We’ve never stumbled upon pink sprinkles before so she just had to give ‘em a try! I indulged in the Chatham Light Bar. The perfect amount of cookie, chocolate chucks and vanilla! I love biting through ice cream while hitting chewy chunks of dough and chocolate chips. I could eat about five more! The atmosphere inside and out was very charming and cozy. Can’t wait to go back for another bite!"

"The cookies that surround the home made ice cream bar are baked by hand by my friend, Nolan Linsky. Outstanding"

"Thinking about the girl who posed for a photo for her social media and them promptly handed it back to her man exclaiming, “Here, I don’t want this.” Can I have it? The pistachios on my banana split were absolute perfection!"

"I ordered maple walnuts which is great! It’s not over sweetened and the walnuts smell great. They made these two in a perfect mix!"

"I guess this place is famous because it has been here for some time, but to be honest, I was not dazzled. The local Emock & Bolio's franchise is also in town and for my money is better ice cream. The famous 'Chatham Ice Cream Bars' may have been a fun novelty at some point, but now they are mass produced and you may faint when you read the massive list of ingredients and see how many are preservatives and fillers. Also they are very sweet (too sweet), I was underwhelmed. The staff was very nice, but I sense this shop has lost it's way as a local ice cream provider and is instead just looking to sell their bars on a mass market scale. Again, it's not bad, but there's definitely better ice cream to be found elsewhere."