Tutto il Giorno Sag

"There is no other restaurant in the Hamptons as reliable and consistent as Tutto Il Giorno, Sag Harbor. From the food, to the wine, to the service, it’s simply perfect every time. If you’re dining here in the winter, don’t miss the Tortelli."

"Probably one of the prettiest restaurants in the Hamptons. With a gorgeous patio and indoor space, decorated in a stunning beach chic decor, this is the place to see and be seen in the Hamptons. The food is great “most” of the time (recently I had a butternut squash soup for my appetizer that was tasteless), and some of the dishes can blend at times. During the high season, you cannot get a table without a reservation, so plan to wait over 2 hours if you do a walk-in (sometimes they won’t even be able to accommodate you). The menu prices are true to Hampton prices, so don’t be shocked to pay over $30 for a glass of wine, and upwards of $130 for the most inexpensive bottle. The last few times we were there, we felt cheated (the check was outrageously expensive and the food wasn’t that great)."

"I ate here for lunch and was not a huge fan of their food. However, the place was nice and the staff were AMAZING, which is why i added an extra star. The food though.. is a diff story. I got the tuna tartare and that was not very good. Got the spaghetti as well and that wasnt the best either. It didnt have any meat on it… for $30…? Come onnn"

"My favorite restaurant in all of the Hamptons. Excellent restaurant all around. The food is incredible especially the spaghetti “scarpariello”. Wine is terrific and the ambiance is romantic and homey at the same time. Highly recommend. And it’s open all year round for us locals."

"We were in Sag Harbor on a moderately cold March afternoon and walked by this place which was yet to open at around 3 pm. After getting a drink from a near by bar, we showed up again at 3:45 and their team was kind enough to get seating in a wonderfully setup outdoor area. They noticed we were all cold, and so was our 2 year old, and their super helpful and friendly staff put 4 outdoor heaters in 4 corners for us so we could enjoy our time here. And what a fabulous experience we had. Their entire team is absolutely amazing and they mixed some powerful and tasty cocktails for our group. We had just come back from lunch, so weren't that hungry, but everytime we passed the kitchen the aroma from food was just making us a but hungry which made us order their Risotto ($35) and Tortelli ($34) which our server suggested. Now, in my opinion, Indian's are the biggest critiques of Italian food and often times find it bland, thanks to our "sometimes" overpowering, yet flavorful spices, so the expectation was quite low - but were we surprised when presented with one of the most flavorful and delicious Italian food we've ever had! We were running late for a dinner reservation, which we couldn't cancel at the last minute, else this was an absolute perfect place to wine and dine! This place is bookmarked as one of our favorites and special thanks to the super friendly team at Tutto for a wonderful evening filled with excellent ambiance, food, and service. Will definitely visit again!"