Peel Pizza Company 538 Adams Street, Milton, MA 02186

"Ordered 2 pies on a school night: 1 hr later, called, girl said IDK where the delivery guy is, try calling back. 1.5 later called again, she said driver was AWOL, but don't worry, we'll hook you up with free pizza another night... Next night, call to get our "free pizza," guy said let me look into it, never called back. I can't blame the place for having a bad driver, but please stand by your pledge to make up for it."

"Really good pizza! Our order did not go through somehow and we were in a rush with our hungry baby in the car. The person working the store at the time graciously offered us a pizza that a customer had not picked up. True savior! We will come back, this time with our order truly placed! Thank you!"

"I was impressed that the place that lists take out and dine in option does not have an on-site bathroom. Very hard to appreciate when a small kid asks to use a bathroom, it cannot be accommodated while we ordered and we’re waiting for our pizza…. Certainly an area to improve for future customers."

"I was told this place was supposed to be amazing. Well I ordered from them an hour before they were closing on Uber eats. I got a Hawaiian and a margarita pizza. It had to be the worst tasting pizza I have ever eaten. The Hawaiian looked as if someone dropped it on the floor and then through it in the box. The taste was unbearable. I don't think I have ever not finished a pizza."

"This was a super letdown after having such a great experience at the Hingham location. I arrived a few minutes early, but overall it was timely as they handed it to me right out of the oven. I then had a short 9 minute ride home, only to experience shame and disappointment. It sucks when you talk up the food to guests, only to have everyone be super unimpressed and full of regret after the meal. Ordered wings, 1 large cheese and 1 large clam chowder pizza. The wings were well seasoned, and I like that they don't smother them in any sauces and let the plain flavor shine. However these wings were overcooked and super dry - no indication of any moisture left. An order came with 9 wings. Now onto the pizzas - both were also incredibly overcooked. The crust and dough were so dry, that our mouths and teeth were sore after dinner from pulling, shredding, and trying to chew. Literally cut up our mouths because they were sharp croutons at that point. Also had to actively search for clams on the clam chowder pizza - found maybe 8 tops. Overall such a disappointment since we had great wings and pizza from another location and were excited to try to Milton one. Will not be ordering from here again. Ordering/delivery also available through doordash and ubereats. Street parking can be a pain around dinner time and will likely have to double park to run in and grab."