The Frisky Oyster

"Had my birthday dinner this past weekend at The Frisky Oyster. Everyone at the table loved the food! The crab cakes, charred prawns and short ribs were delicious! The service on the other hand was terrible. Someone took our order and came back two more times to confirm what we ordered. Our waitress was not attentive at all! The restaurant was not even that busy at 9pm…I expected better!"

"I'm not sure why there have been so many recent negative results for The Frisky Oyster. I actually think that Frisky was better than another more highly rated restaurant in town. The atmosphere is moody and not sterile. The service is attentive and also friendly. Our food was very delicious and inventive. Clearly a nice restaurant and definitely recommend this for a special occasion or just a great dinner."

"The service is outstanding - everyone is attentive and friendly. They're familiar with the menu and give great guidance. It's a beautiful spot - moodier than most restaurants on the North Fork. A great choice for a romantic night. They have a good cocktail menu and nice wine list. The food was disappointing but hopefully it was just an off night."

"The hubs and I came here one night for the first time and we loved it. Everything in town was closed and they were the only ones open later than other spots. The atmosphere can be a bit intimidating but once you get past that idea, its super comfy. Service was fast and staff was friendly. Aside from coming here because they were the only ones open, we came for oysters and drinks. Sadly, they only had two options on the menu for oysters. I was hoping they would have more options with oysters given that their name is Frisky Oyster. The drinks were amazing and the prices were pretty high BUT look at the location. Would we come here again? Maybe but not any time soon."

"Just went here for my anniversary with my fiancée. This place was insanely good. Apologies for the low light pics, we were in the back corner but the ambience was immense. Every cocktail we had was super tasty, and because of this place, we’ve been making a lot of spicy watermelon margaritas. We started with the grilled lobster quesadilla, which was very good and moved on to the peconic gold oyster friskafella which was insanely good. Seriously. Absolutely PACKED with flavor, and a must have when going. Next, we had the lobster gigli pasta which I thought was tasty, but the real star of the show for the entrees was the pomegranate bbq beef short ribs. I’m a short rib fan, and I thought the pomegranate sauce they used was a perfect compliment. We also subbed the cauliflower purée for creamy garlic polenta, which is definitely the way to go in my opinion. I thought this place was perfect. Service was good, cocktails were great, and the food was amazing and flavorful. Check this place out for a special dinner, or just a regular one if you’re in the mood for a damn good meal."