The Pizzeria of Lake Grove

"Great pizza, super kind and friendly people. We will for sure always come back to this location. The uncle Benny is our favorite"

"We have had pizza here before a while ago and it was good. I dont know what happened but today we ordered a Regular pie and it had no taste at all it was like eating cardboard. Im hoping it was just a bad night."

"I work in the mall and eat this Pizza regularly. I have never gotten sick of it and can honestly say its the best pizza place around. The staff is so friendly and the pizza is amazing."

"When I think of NY pizza, this is the ideal that I’m looking for. Great crust with just the right amount of crisp. Delicious sauce. The perfect amount of cheese. And plenty of extra topping options for when you’re craving a little more than a basic slice. Round or square, it’s all really good here. The best and the most consistent pizza to be found on Long Island. I come here time and time again and never ever leave disappointed. Too many places, even ones rated an 8+ by El Pres Portnoy are hit or miss, and sometimes they miss by a lot. But this place is never a miss when I stop for a bite at the mall. Same goes for delivery from this location or the Bayport spot. Plus, they’re one of the only, maybe the only, pizza places to carry glass bottle Mexican Coke which makes my wife an extra happy customer every time. Thank you to The Pizzeria staff for dozens of great meals. I always eat a ton and still I am always left wishing I could fit even more."

"This place was reasonably priced and very filling. I had 2 chicken slices with some tangy sauce on it. They were delicious I easily could have eaten the pie. They have so many choices to choose from I will definitely have to come back here again to try another slice or 12. They were very professional and polite. I found out about them on Long Island Foodies and they never disappoint. Next time I'm over here I will need to try this Buffalo knot I keep hearing about."